Tuesday, July 5, 2011

Changing Attitude : UK House of Bishops statement on civil partnerships and same-sex relationships

Thirteen years after the Lambeth Conference 1998 launched the listening process the House of Bishops has committed itself to a wider look at the Church of England’s approach to same-sex relationships more generally and will produce a consultation document in 2013.

The bishops intend to draw together material from the listening process which has been undertaken within the Church of England over the recent years and offer proposals on how the continuing discussion within the Church of England about these matters might best be shaped in the light of the listening process.

I feel sorry for Graham James, Bishop of Norwich, to whom fell the lot of speaking on behalf of the House. So the House is going to spend two years producing a consultation document, and only in 2013 will they allow the rest of the Church to engage in ‘continuing discussion’.

The bishops are in disarray. Changing Attitude has been told this by a number of bishops. We know from personal experience that the bishops are in disarray. Some recommend for ministry lesbian and gay people who have contracted civil partnerships (and these people are not celibate). Some license lesbian and gay clergy who are in civil partnerships and some actively encourage them to enter civil partnerships. Other bishops are either ignorant of this practice or naïve.

The statement says you have spent little time in recent years discussing homosexuality. I am not surprised by this admission. It’s too uncomfortable to talk about openly amongst yourselves, isn’t it? It’s too personal for some. You should have been talking about it, some of the time, because it affects us deeply, it affects you personally, and it’s the issue that’s affecting the future of our Communion.

The House of Bishops ‘recognise that bishops and clergy have found ways of engaging pastorally with those in civil partnerships, both at the time of registration and subsequently’. What the bishops mean, but don’t say, is that some of them have found ways of fully supporting people in civil partnerships but they don’t want to admit so publicly (or to each other).

The House of Bishops disagrees in practice on the policy it claims to have adopted. It isn’t split. It simply reflects the diversity of the Church of England. The House already contains a number of bishops who are gay and many others who are fully supportive of lesbian and gay relationships.

What the House of Bishops needs to do, NOW, URGENTLY, is to find a way of being open, honest and trusting when bishops meet together, so that the wisdom and experience in their midst can be shared and used to change attitudes NOW.

We, the church, do not need to wait another 2 years for the bishops to produce a consultation document. Come and talk with us now as well as talking openly amongst yourselves for the first time. Talk with the majority of members of the Church of England, talk with those who are lesbian, gay, bisexual, transgender, heterosexual, both lay and ordained, talk with parents, friends, aunts and uncles, talk – and listen.

You have a problem amongst yourselves, bishops, and you have a problem in the Church. Some of you know what people in congregations think and feel about LGB&T people and you are afraid to voice your opinions publicly. I know this because some of you have told me.

Today’s statement is designed to deal with a House of Bishops problem. You may have decided to spend two years producing a consultation document. It may be as ineffective as ‘Some Issues in Human Sexuality’.

We who are the Church, we in Changing Attitude and in other groups working for change, are already living into a new Christian paradigm. We are tired of your prevarication and fear of truth. We are tired of being asked to suppress our God-given identities and deny our natural, God-given sexual instincts. We are tired of being asked to forgo love and relationship until the bishops have come to a common mind about the teaching of the church.

In 2013 the House of Bishops will be even more divorced from the reality of our real lives and of the practice of the church. It has now agreed that the time has come to review the 2005 statement on civil partnerships including whether priests in civil partnerships should be eligible for appointment as bishops. The review will be completed in 2012. As others have commented, this seems deliberately designed to be personal, to avoid any diocese recommending the appointment of Jeffrey John.

Thirteen years after the Lambeth Conference 1998 launched the listening process the House of Bishops has committed itself to a wider look at the Church of England’s approach to same-sex relationships more generally and will produce a consultation document in 2013.

The bishops intend to draw together material from the listening process which has been undertaken within the Church of England over the recent years and offer proposals on how the continuing discussion within the Church of England about these matters might best be shaped in the light of the listening process.

I feel sorry for Graham James, Bishop of Norwich, to whom fell the lot of speaking on behalf of the House. So the House is going to spend two years producing a consultation document, and only in 2013 will they allow the rest of the Church to engage in ‘continuing discussion’.

The bishops are in disarray. Changing Attitude has been told this by a number of bishops. We know from personal experience that the bishops are in disarray. Some recommend for ministry lesbian and gay people who have contracted civil partnerships (and these people are not celibate). Some license lesbian and gay clergy who are in civil partnerships and some actively encourage them to enter civil partnerships. Other bishops are either ignorant of this practice or naïve.

The statement says you have spent little time in recent years discussing homosexuality. I am not surprised by this admission. It’s too uncomfortable to talk about openly amongst yourselves, isn’t it? It’s too personal for some. You should have been talking about it, some of the time, because it affects us deeply, it affects you personally, and it’s the issue that’s affecting the future of our Communion.

The House of Bishops ‘recognise that bishops and clergy have found ways of engaging pastorally with those in civil partnerships, both at the time of registration and subsequently’. What the bishops mean, but don’t say, is that some of them have found ways of fully supporting people in civil partnerships but they don’t want to admit so publicly (or to each other).

The House of Bishops disagrees in practice on the policy it claims to have adopted. It isn’t split. It simply reflects the diversity of the Church of England. The House already contains a number of bishops who are gay and many others who are fully supportive of lesbian and gay relationships.

What the House of Bishops needs to do, NOW, URGENTLY, is to find a way of being open, honest and trusting when bishops meet together, so that the wisdom and experience in their midst can be shared and used to change attitudes NOW.

We, the church, do not need to wait another 2 years for the bishops to produce a consultation document. Come and talk with us now as well as talking openly amongst yourselves for the first time. Talk with the majority of members of the Church of England, talk with those who are lesbian, gay, bisexual, transgender, heterosexual, both lay and ordained, talk with parents, friends, aunts and uncles, talk – and listen.

You have a problem amongst yourselves, bishops, and you have a problem in the Church. Some of you know what people in congregations think and feel about LGB&T people and you are afraid to voice your opinions publicly. I know this because some of you have told me.

Today’s statement is designed to deal with a House of Bishops problem. You may have decided to spend two years producing a consultation document. It may be as ineffective as ‘Some Issues in Human Sexuality’.

We who are the Church, we in Changing Attitude and in other groups working for change, are already living into a new Christian paradigm. We are tired of your prevarication and fear of truth. We are tired of being asked to suppress our God-given identities and deny our natural, God-given sexual instincts. We are tired of being asked to forgo love and relationship until the bishops have come to a common mind about the teaching of the church.

In 2013 the House of Bishops will be even more divorced from the reality of our real lives and of the practice of the church. It has now agreed that the time has come to review the 2005 statement on civil partnerships including whether priests in civil partnerships should be eligible for appointment as bishops. The review will be completed in 2012. As others have commented, this seems deliberately designed to be personal, to avoid any diocese recommending the appointment of Jeffrey John.

Changing Attitude is campaigning for change NOW! We want civil partnerships in church NOW! We want an end to the discrimination against LGB&T lay and ordained ministers NOW! We want freedom for the church to appoint those in civil partnerships NOW!

Talk with us now, bishops. Invite us to a House of Bishops meeting. Perhaps we can help you find the way to be honest amongst yourselves.

Changing Attitude is campaigning for change NOW! We want civil partnerships in church NOW! We want an end to the discrimination against LGB&T lay and ordained ministers NOW! We want freedom for the church to appoint those in civil partnerships NOW!

Talk with us now, bishops. Invite us to a House of Bishops meeting. Perhaps we can help you find the way to be honest amongst yourselves.

Monday, July 4, 2011

A "Pastoral" letter from the Bishop of Albany?


From OPENLY EPISCOPAL IN ALBANY

When the following letter was read to our congregation this Sunday, July 3rd, 2011, as ordered by Bishop Love (Shown at left) , you could have heard a pin drop. As the rector began her recitation, a loud thunderclap from a passing summer storm only served to increase the tension. When the letter noted that "New York has now joined five other states in redefining marriage," there was loud and sustained appause from the congregation. Where the letter referred to diocesan canon that "specifically bars any other union" than that between one man and one woman, there arose an audible hiss. When the Bishop expressed his expectation that all "the clergy and laity of the Diocese Albany" will support him in upholding diocesan canon over the law of New York, more than one head was shaking in disbelief.

Compare the legalistic response of the Bishop of Albany with the pastoral and welcoming responses of the Bishop of Long Island, The Bishop of Western New York, and other dioceses across our state.

In one thing the Bishop of Albany is correct, when he states that "this has been and is a very emotional and highly charged issue." Speak up if you are one of the "very well meaning people" who welcomes the action of the New York Legislature, and who find the restrictive canon of the Diocese of Albany to be now, more than ever, discriminatory.

'God of Liberty': The Role of Religion in American Independence

For some relevant reading on this Independence Three-Day Weekend, one can hardly do better than "God of Liberty: A Religious History of the American Revolution". At a time when both American history and religion are hotly contested territory -- caught between purported dichotomies of holiness and nihilism, theocracy and secularism, provincialism and pluralism -- a bit of perspective, fact-checking and a brief immersion into the genesis of an independent America is in order.

"God of Liberty" dispels the false dilemmas by showing that America has always been religious -- and also religiously diverse. The historical narrative suggests that it's this special combination to which the United States owes its existence, and this that made the American Revolution so revolutionary. MORE by Anil Mundra @ HuffPost

Sunday, July 3, 2011

CofE: No Gay Bishops Now - So What If That's Discrimination?

Civil partnerships and same-sex relationships - a statement by the House of Bishops of the Church of England

The House of Bishops today issued a statement about the continuing debate within the Church of England about same-sex relationships. Speaking on behalf of the House, the Bishop of Norwich, the Rt Revd Graham James, said:

“Contrary to popular perception the House of Bishops has spent very little time over recent years discussing homosexuality. The last substantive engagement with the issue was in 2005 when the House agreed to issue a pastoral statement prepared by a group under my chairmanship on the implications of the introduction of civil partnerships. The House has now agreed that the time has come to commission two new pieces of work.

“First it has asked for a review of the 2005 statement in the light of subsequent developments. The review will include examination of whether priests in civil partnerships should be eligible for appointment as bishops. The 2005 statement was silent on this issue and, while the relevant legal background was analysed in a recently published Legal Office note, the House acknowledges its responsibility to address the policy issue. To avoid pre-empting the outcome of the review the House has concluded that clergy in civil partnerships should not, at present, be nominated for episcopal appointment. The review will be completed in 2012.

“Secondly, the House has committed itself to a wider look at the Church of England’s approach to same-sex relationships more generally in the light of the listening process launched by the Lambeth Conference in 1998. The Bishops will produce a consultation document in 2013. The House’s decision is motivated by a desire to help shape the continuing debate constructively and not by any view about what the outcome should be.”

The statement follows:

A Statement from the House of Bishops of the Church of England

“It is now nearly six years since the House issued its Pastoral Statement prior to the introduction of civil partnerships in December 2005. The preparation of that document was the last occasion when the House devoted substantial time to the issue of same sex relationships. We undertook to keep that Pastoral Statement under review. We have decided that the time has come for a review to take place.

“Over the past five and half years there have been several developments. Consistent with the guidelines in the Pastoral Statement a number of clergy are now in civil partnerships. The General Synod decided to amend the clergy pension scheme to improve the provision for the surviving civil partners of clergy who have died. More recently Parliament has decided that civil partnerships may be registered on religious premises where the relevant religious authority has consented (the necessary regulations are expected this autumn).

“The review will need to take account of this changing scene. The Pastoral Statement was not concerned with clergy alone but with the whole people of God. We recognise that bishops and clergy have found ways of engaging pastorally with those in civil partnerships, both at the time of registration and subsequently. Within the Anglican tradition our theological thinking is formed by a reasoned interpretation of Scripture, within the living tradition of the Church informed by pastoral experience. The House believes there is a theological task to be done to clarify further our understanding of the nature and status of these partnerships.

“These are the background issues for a review of the 2005 Statement. It will be undertaken in the context of the Church of England’s teaching on same sex relations as set out in the General Synod motion of November 1987 and Issues in Human Sexuality (a teaching statement from the House of Bishops in 1991). It will also be consistent with the approach taken by the Anglican Communion in Resolution 1.10 of the Lambeth Conference 1998 and subsequently.

“Among the matters to be considered in the review of the 2005 Statement there is one of some importance which the House did not address in advance of any experience of civil partnerships. This is whether clergy who have registered civil partnerships should be eligible for nomination to the episcopate. The House has concluded that it would be wrong to pre-empt the outcome of the review and that clergy in civil partnerships should not at present, therefore, be nominated for episcopal appointment. The House’s intention is to complete the review, which will need to take account of the legal analysis set out in GS MISC 992 (Choosing Bishops - the Equality Act) during 2012.

“The House has also decided that more work is now needed on the Church of England’s approach to human sexuality more generally. In February 2007, the General Synod passed a motion commending ‘continuing efforts to prevent the diversity of opinion about human sexuality creating further division and impaired fellowship within the Church of England and the Anglican Communion.’

“Alongside the review of the 2005 Pastoral Statement, the House intends, therefore, to draw together material from the listening process which has been undertaken within the Church of England over the recent years in the light of the 1998 Lambeth Conference resolution. The House wishes to offer proposals on how the continuing discussion within the Church of England about these matters might best be shaped in the light of the listening process. Our intention is to produce a further consultation document in 2013.”

The statement has been issued to General Synod members today, as GS Misc 997E. It is available on the Church of England website at http://www.churchofengland.org/media/1289380/gsmisc997.pdf.

The Torah, The Constitution, and the 4th of July

{A}s we celebrate this 4th of July, let us be grateful that we live in one of the freest countries ever to exist, yet we are not perfect. The Constitution must never be allowed to become an idol, just as the Torah must never be allowed to become an idol. One midrash teaches that Moses shattered the first tablets as a reminder of that notion. We must always do battle between fear and liberty, between power and freedom. That is the great gift, and great challenge, of being human. Thomas Jefferson said it best, when he wrote, "All, too, will bear in mind this sacred principle, that though the will of the majority is in all cases to prevail, that will, to be rightful, must be reasonable; that the minority possess their equal rights, which equal laws must protect, and to violate which would be oppression." That is our great challenge, as Americans and as Jews. May we ponder deeply on this, our nation's birthday. Shabbat shalom and God bless America." MORE

Follow Rabbi Joshua Levine Grater on Twitter: www.twitter.com/rabbijoshua

Saturday, July 2, 2011

Task force releases report on Anglican Covenant


[Episcopal News Service] An Executive Council task force has released a report it received from the Standing Commission on Constitution and Canons outlining the changes that would be needed if the General Convention decides to sign onto the Anglican Covenant.

"The SCCC is of the view that adoption of the current draft Anglican Covenant has the potential to change the constitutional and canonical framework of [the Episcopal Church], particularly with respect to the autonomy of our Church, and the constitutional authority of our General Convention, bishops and dioceses," says the report.

In a statement June 24, the D023 (Anglican Covenant) task force wrote that it has released the report now because of "legitimate concerns raised about issues of transparency around a decision as important for our Church as the Anglican Covenant."

Rosalie Simmonds Ballentine, chair of the task force, told the June 15-17 meeting of Executive Council that the group would not yet release the report. "We're reluctant to have it out there" because some people may assume that decisions have already been made, she told council, noting that the document would eventually form part of the Blue Book report to the 77th General Convention.

In the aftermath of the council meeting, a number of bloggers and other observers called on the task force to release the report before publication of the Blue Book report, a draft of which is expected to be received by Executive Council in October.

"We regret that our initial decision to withhold release of the SCCC report, which was requested as a resource to assist the drafting of the Blue Book Report, caused such distress to some in this Church," said the task force in its June 24 statement. "There is not and has not been any intent to be secretive, nor was there any intent to imply that Episcopalians are not capable of accurately assessing the information in this report."

The 2009 meeting of General Convention asked, via Resolution D020, that the church's dioceses study the proposed covenant and report to Executive Council. Presiding Bishop Katharine Jefferts Schori, President of the House of Deputies Bonnie Anderson and Ballentine asked bishops and diocesan General Convention deputations to respond by April 24 so that council could consider their comments as it prepares a report to next year's meeting of General Convention, as requested in Resolution D020.

Ballentine told council that there were "a few" among the 64 responses the group received from a request for comment on the final draft of the covenant that would approve the covenant in full. "Almost all" respondents objected to Section 4, which contained a disciplinary process, she said.

The Anglican Covenant first was proposed in the 2004 Windsor Report as a way that the communion and its 38 autonomous provinces might maintain unity despite differences, especially relating to biblical interpretation and human sexuality issues.

But some Episcopalians and Anglicans, including Jefferts Schori and the Executive Council, have raised concerns about the covenant being used as an instrument of control, particularly in section 4, which outlines a method for resolving disputes in the communion.

Following years of discussion and several draft versions, the final text of the covenant was sent in December 2009 to the provinces for formal consideration.

Executive Council has predicted that formal approval of the covenant by the Episcopal Church could not come until at least 2015 should endorsement require changes to the church's constitution; hence the request for the church's Standing Commission on Constitution and Canons to offer its report. Constitutional changes require approval by two consecutive meetings of the church's triennial convention

The Battle Beneath the Battle: Do Gay People Exist?


BY JAY MICHAELSON

There’s a cognitive dissonance in our religious and political debates about homosexuality: it’s the only cultural struggle I can think of where one’s very existence is routinely denied by political opponents. Read more.